Preface
Acknowledgments
About the Author
Part I. Foundations
CHAPTER 1: Why Adult Development Matters in the Context of Education Today
What Do We Mean by a Developmental Approach?
How Developmental Capacity Helps Us Meet Current Challenges in Education
Technical and Adaptive Challenges
Acknowledging Developmental Diversity
Introducing the Four Pillar Practices
Caring Is the Heart of Our Work
The Evidence Base for This Book
Developmental Underpinnings of the Model
The Turbulent Context of Education Today
Teachers: Retention, Burnout, and Well-Being
Burnout and Work–Life Balance: A Persistent Struggle
Social-Emotional Learning Can Help Retain Teachers
Supporting Teacher Well-Being: A Systemic Imperative
Expanding Roles and Rising Demands Drive Principal Attrition
Supporting Principals for Long-Term Retention
A Foundational Strategy: Building Supportive Networks and Fostering Collaboration
Contemporary Issues in Education and the World
Key Factors Influencing Our Postpandemic Context
The “New Normal” as a Catalyst for Change
Social Justice in Education: A Call to Action
Technology and AI: Navigating the Future of Education
Broader Societal and Environmental Challenges
What We Know: Professional Learning Is Like Oxygen for Educators and Leaders Across the System
New Roles for Leaders Demand a Developmental Approach
The Power of Transformational Learning Across the System
CHAPTER 2: Constructive-Developmental Theory
Constructive-Developmental Theory and Transformational Learning
History of Constructive-Developmental Theory
Foundations for Understanding Constructive-Developmental Theory
Constructivism, Developmentalism, and Subject–Object Balance—How Do We See and Make Sense?
Self and Other, Subject and Object—How Do We See and Make Sense?
Orienting to the Ways of Knowing
Moving From One Way of Knowing to the Next
What Ways of Knowing Are—And Are Not
Ways of Knowing: Developmental Strengths, Supports, Growing Edges, and Stretches
The Instrumental Way of Knowing: Rule-Oriented Self
Supports, Growing Edges, and Developmental Stretches
A Real-Life Example (A Principal’s Experience)
The Socializing Way of Knowing: Other-Focused Self
Supports, Growing Edges, and Developmental Stretches
A Real-Life Example (Working With Yee)
The Self-Authoring Way of Knowing: Reflective Self (Also Sometimes Referred to as “Systems-Focused”)
Supports, Growing Edges, and Developmental Stretches
A Real-Life Example (Working with Ale)
The Self-Transforming Way of Knowing: Interconnecting Self
Why This Stage Is Hard to Pin Down
The Transition: Both Liberating and Disorienting
Characteristics of Self-Transforming Knowers
Supports, Growing Edges, and Developmental Stretches
A Learning-Oriented Model of Leadership and Developmental Awareness
Preconditions for Supporting Adult Development
Psychological Safety as a Form of Holding Environment
Why They Matter in Practice
Expanding Openness and Reducing Blind Spots
No Such Thing as a “Little Trust Problem”
Different Ways of Knowing: A Developmental View of Safety, Trust, and Respect
The Holding Environment and Why It Matters for Adults in Teams, Schools, Districts—Everywhere!
The Three Functions of a Holding Environment
Growing the Growers—About Wings and Butterflies
Frequently Asked Questions
Application Exercise 2.1: Shaping Team, School, and District Cultures: Noble Expectations and Hidden Developmental Demands
Application Exercise 2.2: Attending to Ways of Knowing
Questions to Consider in Relation to Box 2.1
PART II: PILLAR PRACTICES FOR GROWTH
CHAPTER 3: Teaming: Growth Opportunities for Individuals, Organizations, and Systems
How Teaming Has Changed—And Remained the Same
How This Chapter Will Discuss Effective Teaming
A Roadmap for This Chapter
Teaming in the Literature Today
The Importance of Teaming
Conditions Research Shows Make for Great Teams . . .
. . . And a Word About the Use of Time
The Need to Build Collaborative Cultures and Safe Spaces
What Do Educators Value About Teaming?
The Team as a Source of Individual Development: Engaging in Reflective Practice
The Bedrock of Teaming: Trust
About Vulnerability, Trust, and Teaming
More About Psychological Safety and Its Importance to a Developmental Approach
Attending to Developmental Diversity
The Instrumental Knower as Team Member
The Socializing Knower as Team Member
The Self-Authoring Knower as Team Member
The Self-Transforming Knower as Team Member
The Value of the Developmental Perspective in Teaming
What I’ve Learned About Teaming From School and District Leaders
What Leaders at All Levels Taught Me About Teaming
Dr. Myatt, Fenway Pilot High School
Mr. Beshir Abdell, Assistant Principal, Bayside High School, New York City
Ms. Christina Vittiglio, Teacher-Leader, Francis Lewis High School, New York City
How Effective Teaming Promotes Adult Development
Establishing Ground Rules, Norms, and Commitments
On Powerful Norms, Open Dialogue, and the Need for Safe and Brave Spaces
A Word About Safe and Brave Spaces
Sample Norms, Agreements, Guidelines From Teams in the Field—And Two Tales of Norm Setting
Building Norms Helped One School After a Year of COVID-19
A High-Trust, High-Functioning Team
Framing Questions to Attend to Ways of Knowing
Assessing Team Performance
Additional Protocols for Furthering Team Progress
Implementing Teaming: Stories and Lessons From the Field
Adults Need Spaces for Vulnerability—A Principal’s Realization
How a Principal Used the Pillars to Guide Teams
A Fresh Start in Leading a Grade-Level Team
A Protocol for Teaming Dilemmas
Frequently Asked Questions
Application Exercise 3.1: Bridge to Practice
Application Exercise 3.2: Capitalizing on Developmental Strengths and Growing Edges of Teammates
CHAPTER 4: Offering Leadership Roles: Learning and Growing From Leading Together
About Offering Leadership Roles
How Is Offering Leadership Roles Different From Distributing Leadership?
What the Literature Says About Offering Leadership Roles
The New Keys for Leading in Complex Times
Pathways for Sharing Leadership
The Principal’s Role: Relationships and Leadership Style
Needed: Structural Supports and Clear Expectations for Leadership
Current Thinking About Teacher Leadership
Developmental Benefits of Offering Leadership Roles
Relating Leadership Roles to Ways of Knowing: Pulling the Developmental Thread
The Instrumental Knower as Leader
The Socializing Knower as Leader
The Self-Authoring Knower as Leader
The Self-Transforming Knower as Leader
The Leadership Role as Holding Environment
What I’ve Learned About Offering Leadership Roles from Schools and District Leaders
Offering Leadership Roles to Teachers and to Principals
Barriers to Offering Leadership Roles
Learning From Leadership Roles
Supports for Those Assuming Leadership Roles
Examples of Leaders’ Use of Offering Leadership Roles
Principals Offering Leadership Roles for Teachers
Building Capacity by Offering Leadership Roles at Middle School 88 in Park Slope, Brooklyn
The Case: In Principal Mitchell’s Voice
Implementing Teaming and Lifting Teacher-Leaders
How Teams Functioned and Were Supported
Impact and Observed Benefits of Our Approach
My Insights—and Tips and Takeaways
Teacher Leadership Roles Inside the School
Teacher Leadership Roles Outside the School
Principals Assuming Additional Leadership Roles
Principals as Mentors and Coaches to Aspiring and Practicing Principals
Principals as Facilitators of Conversations With Newer Principals
Principals Assuming Leadership Roles in Collaborative Inquiry Groups
The Case: Leading for Sustainable Change (In Dr. Wilson’s Voice)
Offering Leadership Roles and Self-Insight—And Outcomes of the Approach
My Reflections on the Process—And Some Takeaways
Teachers Assuming Their Own Additional Leadership Roles
How One Leader Offers Teachers Leadership Roles Within Schools and Districts
Cases and Lessons From the Field
Growing Into and From a Leadership Role—Peter’s Story
Jenni’s Story: Stuck in the Middle
Edgar’s Story: Changing a Math Program Through Teaming and Inviting Teachers Into Leadership
Christy’s Case: Offering Leadership Roles and Developmentally Intentional PD
Application Exercise 4.2: Insightful Questions to Ask Colleagues
CHAPTER 5: Mentoring: Building Meaningful and Growth-Enhancing Relationships
Mentoring: Origin and Overview
Key Definitions and Roles of Mentors
Mentoring in the Professional Development Literature: Across Sectors
The Benefits of Mentoring
Learning to Be a Good Mentor
Mentoring as a Lever for Equity
Mentoring in the Professional Development Literature: In K–12 Education
The Link Between Mentoring and Retention
Mentoring Helps Mentors, Too
Mentoring School Leaders and Administrators
A Note on Coaching in K–12 Education and Leadership Contexts
Effective Coaching Doesn’t Work in a Vacuum: Culture Matters
Coaching and Cultural Sensitivity
The Emotional and Intellectual Weight of Coaching
The Inner Life of the Coach
Mentoring in the Adult Development Literature
The Mentoring Relationship
Mentoring as a Holding Environment for Growth
How a Mentor Can Offer Supports
How a Mentor Can Provide Challenges—Stretching (When the Person Is Ready)
Key Things to Keep in Mind
About Building Mentoring Programs—A Developmental Perspective
Mentoring and Developmental Diversity
Relating Ways of Knowing to Mentoring
The Instrumental Knower as Mentee
The Socializing Knower as Mentee
The Self-Authoring Knower as Mentee
The Self-Transforming Knower as Mentee
How Our Way of Knowing Influences How We Mentor
Why and How School and District Leaders Employ Mentoring
Examples of Principals’ Use of Mentoring to Support Teachers’ Growth and Learning
General Features of Mentoring Programs Used by Principals
Programs for Beginning Teachers
Mentoring Teachers in Using Technology
An Example of Principals’ Mentoring Assistant Principals’ Learning
Characteristics of “Good Mentors”
What Supports Mentees Most Want
What Mentors Feel Most Proud Of
Some Themes in District-Level Leaders’ Use of Mentoring
Implementing Mentoring and Coaching: Stories From the Field
A View From a Successful Mentoring Program
A Transformative Mentorship: Redefining Wellness in Leadership Through Coaching and Mentoring
Learning to Prioritize Wellness Through Mentorship: In Jullia Lim’s Voice
A Shift to Prioritizing Emotional and Mental Well-Being
Embracing a Comprehensive Approach to Wellness
The Impact of Mentorship on My Life
Developmental Mentoring in a Bronx High School
Supporting Adult Development in Schools: In Michael Barakat’s Voice
Meeting—and Mentoring—Teachers Where They Are
Mentorship: No Quick Fix, but a Powerful Tool
Mentorship as a Catalyst for Continuous Development
Mentoring New Principals in Chicago Public Schools
Meeting the Developmental Needs of First-Year Principals: In Tai Maria Basurto’s Voice
Reflections and Insights—Tips and Takeaways
Growing From Being Coached to Coaching Teachers and Leaders in Australia
The Transformative Power of Coaching for Adult Learning: In Andrea’s Voice
Using Differentiation and Trust-Building in Coaching
Building Others’ Coaching Knowledge and Skills
What These Cases Reveal About Mentoring
A Protocol for Building Mentoring Relationships That Nurture Adult Development
CHAPTER 6: Collegial Inquiry: Engaging in Shared Dialogue and Reflection on Practice
Collegial Inquiry: A Kind of Reflective Practice—And More
Reflective Practice Supports Personal and Professional Learning
Reflective Practice Helps Us Identify Our Assumptions
Reflective Practice Helps Us Reconceptualize Our Assumptions
Building a Culture of Collaborative Reflective Practice
Who Should Engage in Reflective Practice?
Requirements for Engaging in Reflective Practice
Developing Structures for Shared Reflection and Dialogue
Narrative Spotlight: One Teacher’s Call for Safe Spaces
Creating the Conditions for Shared Reflection and Dialogue
Modeling How to Engage in Dialogue and Reflection
Increasing Self-Awareness Through Meaningful Dialogue and Reflection
Acclimating Teachers to a New Culture
How Collegial Inquiry Connects to Developmental Diversity
Relating Collegial Inquiry to Ways of Knowing
The Instrumental Knower and Collegial Inquiry
The Socializing Knower and Collegial Inquiry
The Self-Authoring Knower and Collegial Inquiry
The Self-Transforming Knower and Collegial Inquiry
Collegial Inquiry as a Path to a Different Way of Knowing
Application Spotlight: Goal Setting Across Ways of Knowing
How Leaders Can Developmentally Tailor Goal-Setting Practices With Adult Learners
How Collegial Inquiry Applies to Feedback
Developmental Feedback as a Powerful Form of Collegial Inquiry
Differentiating Feedback for Growth
The Flower Metaphor: Tuning Into Inner Growth
Feedback as a Holding Environment for Growth
Building a Feedback Culture Through Collegial Inquiry
Giving and Receiving Feedback
Application Spotlight: Exercises to Practice Developmental Feedback
Application Exercise 1: Questions for Checking in and Requesting Feedback on Your Coaching/Training/Leadership Work
Application Exercise 2: Naming Your Feedback Dilemma/Challenge
Application Exercise 3: Practicing Feedback Giving With a Feedback Partner
How and Why Leaders Employ Collegial Inquiry
How Leaders Are Having Collegial Conversations
Engaging in Courageous Conversations
Preparing for Challenging Conversations
Collegial Dialogue in a Racially and Culturally Diverse Public School
Teacher Conversations Within PLCs
Developmental Conversations Between Schools and Families
Practices School Leaders Are Using to Initiate Collegial Inquiry
Practices Used by Principals and Assistant Principals With Teachers and Other Adults
Practice 1: Reflection Through the Process of Writing
Practice 2: Reflection Through Dialogue
Practice 3: Reflection Through Decision-Making
Practice 4: Reflection Through Helping and Advising Others
Practices Used by Principals With Fellow Principals
Practices Used by Teachers With Other Teachers
Practice 1: Initiating Book Clubs
Practice 2: Initiating Groups for Sharing Best Practices
Practice 3: Initiating Groups on Grant and Proposal Writing
Four Case Studies From the Field Using Collegial Inquiry
Dealing With Profound Change: Making Sense of AI and Instructional Redesign
The Challenge of AI in Education: In Jerry Crisci’s Voice
A Prime Opportunity for Collegial Inquiry
Making Time for Mourning and Incorporating Diverse Voices
How This Learning Experience Benefited Teachers
Faculty Self-Identifying Their “Way of Knowing” and Teaming With Complementary “Knowers” for Collegial Conversations
The Ways of Knowing—A New Lens: In Mark Erlenwein’s Voice
The Framework: Merging Ways of Knowing With Trust, Safety, and Respect
The Impact of WOK-Centered Feedback on Leadership and Teaching
Leveraging Collegial Inquiry for Effective Grade Reassignments
Our Challenge and the Pillar of Collegial Inquiry: In Felix and Jennifer’s Voice
Building Trust and Easing in Change
How Collegial Inquiry Benefited Our Community
Insights, Tips, and Takeaways
How One Principal Helped a New Team Bond With Each Other
A Day for Bonding—And Learning From Geese
Setting Goals for Working Better as a Team
An Exercise to Surface Values and Build Trust
Exercise 6.1: Convening: Personal Case-Based Discussions That Support Collegial Inquiry
Exercise 6.2: Goal Setting as an Instructional and Developmental Practice
CHAPTER 7: Futuring Forward
Building Developmental Capacity to Meet Adaptive Challenges
Schools and Districts as Learning Centers
A Learning-Oriented Leadership Model for Promoting Growth
Attending to and Honoring Our Own and Each Other’s Internal Capacities
Valuing Adults’ Ways of Knowing
Supporting Different Ways of Knowing—Without Labeling
Why Developmental Diversity Matters in Leadership and Learning
Putting the New Learning-Oriented Model Into Practice
The Power of Cathedral Thinking as We Try a New Model
Cathedral Thinking in Schools
On This Journey, Renewal and Hope . . .
The Challenge and Promise of Renewal—And Transformation
Love and Listening Make Renewal Possible
A Call to Action: Carrying the Work Forward
Walking in Hope Toward Today’s—And Your Future—Purpose
Epilogue
Glossary
References
Index
Building Developmental Capacity to Meet Adaptive Challenges
Schools and Districts as Learning Centers
A Learning-Oriented Leadership Model for Promoting Growth
Attending to and Honoring Our Own and Each Other’s Internal Capacities
Valuing Adults’ Ways of Knowing
Supporting Different Ways of Knowing—Without Labeling
Why Developmental Diversity Matters in Leadership and Learning
Putting the New Learning-Oriented Model Into Practice
The Power of Cathedral Thinking as We Try a New Model
Cathedral Thinking in Schools
On This Journey, Renewal and Hope . . .
The Challenge and Promise of Renewal—And Transformation
Love and Listening Make Renewal Possible
A Call to Action: Carrying the Work Forward
Walking in Hope Toward Today’s—And Your Future—Purpose
Epilogue
Glossary
References
Index